
Everybody loves a comeback story. And All the Beautiful Things, the first play performed in BYU’s new Arts Building, has nearly a dozen of them. A collaboration between communications and theatre, the production draws from more than 125 interviews with people of many faith traditions who detailed why they left religion and later returned.
“The original title of the play came from one of our Catholic interviewees,” says theatre professor Alexandra Mackenzie Johns (MA ’06), director and cowriter of the play. “After years of miscarriages and then finally having children, she described this transcendent moment driving home where she felt deeply connected to everything and everyone around her—‘God, people, butterflies, and all the beautiful things.’” Johns explains that life’s sorrows “can become the root of our joy” because Christ “makes the hard things beautiful.”
The deeply personal stories emerged from research led by communications professor Jessica Danowski Zurcher (MA ’11), who noticed that scholarship focused primarily on people leaving religion. She determined to learn what “prompted somebody to return to religion after experiencing a crisis of faith.”
The research revealed a pattern: Those who returned often described moments when they felt “seen” and recognized, “I can communicate with God again,” Zurcher says. Seeing the inspiring potential of the stories, Zurcher wondered what they might look like on stage and reached out to BYU’s theatre and media arts program.
All the Beautiful Things premiered in October 2026. “What I hope for is that audiences walk away from the experience feeling seen and heard, that their story is just as valid and hopeful and true as the stories they’ve just seen,” says dramaturg and cowriter Shelley Tuckfield Graham (BA ’01, MA ’04).
“Where’er we wander, where’er we roam,” the actors sang during the play, “We’re always welcome, welcome home.” The new hymn “Welcome Home” and diverse music from many faith traditions bolstered the play’s theme of returning to God. Senior theatre arts student Isabel H. Ownby (BA ’27) underscored and arranged the music, composing a powerful closing medley that combines “Amazing Grace” in English, “How Great Is Our God” in Hebrew, and a tune with a Muslim call to prayer.
Ownby says the play is a call to be patient and listen for “the special ways that God answers our prayers,” and that having questions is part of a healthy faith journey. “The very things that we have doubts about,” she says, “can be the very means by which God brings us back.”