At the Y

Q&A: Seeking Truth and Wisdom


A portrait of Top of Mind host Julie Rose next to a microphone.
Photo by Bradley Slade

Every weekday, BYUradio’s Julie Rose (BA ’97) picks the brains of influential thinkers on current events, science, social issues—whatever people are talking about. Here the Top of Mind host shares how—in a time of division and “fake news”—she gathers trustworthy information.

What inspired Top of Mind?

We felt like people could benefit from a show that seeks to inform, not inflame. If a show gives listeners only the viewpoint they agree with, or if it’s always getting people worked up with emotional rhetoric, there’s no real understanding happening. We wanted to be a place for people to explore all aspects of issues in challenging but respectful conversation.

How do you spot unreliable information?

First of all, if it’s written in a way that makes you react emotionally, be very careful. Misinformation thrives on getting you riled up so you’ll share the story without reading it closely. Also, consider the source: is it a news outlet you’ve heard of before? There are lots of pseudo news websites made to look reputable. People who peddle misinformation want you to believe that they’re the only ones to discover some “shocking” truth. But that’s almost never the case. See if other news outlets are reporting the same story.

If you’re trying to verify a specific fact, try one of the many fact-checking sites out there, like Snopes.com. Even better, look for a primary source. Did a politician really say that? Don’t take a reporter’s word for it. Find a video or transcript of the speech and see for yourself. Finally, beware of stories that are built entirely on anonymous sources. There are good reasons to keep a source anonymous, but the reporter should do it rarely and offer a good reason.

What do you look for in an expert?

My number one rule is No Hot Takes. Cable news shows seem to thrive on experts who are really good at lobbing verbal grenades to rile up the audience or other panelists. Top of Mind needs guests who can engage more deeply.

How do you find impartial sources?

I Google them and note which news outlets are using them as a source. Are they all conservative or liberal? The most credible sources are considered expert by outlets across the political spectrum.

More From This Issue

Feature

Black at BYU

What's it like to be Black on an overwhelmingly White campus? Black members of the BYU community share their stories.

Feature

Who Is the BYU GOAT?

There are dozens of contender for greatest Cougar athlete of all time. Can you pick just one?

Browse the complete Fall 2020 Issue »

More Articles

Feature

What’s Killing Journalism?

The Fourth Estate is in shambles. Experts from Atlantic, Fox News, CNN and more talk how—and who—can save it.

Feature

Ending the Uncivil War

Three speakers argue for a renewal of the public square, where all can be part of a political debate.

Alumni News

Curiosity of the World

Art Rascon, news anchor at the ABC-13 in Houston, is an Emmy Award–winning broadcast journalist.